Directory

Click here to read what this author thinks Simon might have said during each show and after each contestant.

| 8 Perform | 8 Results | 7 Perform | 7 Results | 6 Perform |
Showing posts with label Lauren Alaina. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Lauren Alaina. Show all posts

Thursday, April 28, 2011

6 Results Show – Commentary

| Group Performances | Fan Poll Results |

What if Ryan had asked Simon, "It seems like you were a bit nicer last night in your judge's critiques, is there anything we should know?"
You got a seven figure contract for questions like this? I'm neither nice nor mean in my critiques, I'm quite simply honest. What do developing stars need more than anything? Honesty, Ryan. They need to be told when they're terrible and when they're brilliant. When the star quality hits the stage, someone should say so. If my comments seemed more supportive, it might be a produce of eliminating those where were ghastly from the competition. This season, despite all the hype, come finalists who were actually terrible. I don't see many of them going on to anything even remotely related to music. We are finally down to a group that can sing and could be the next American Idol.

Running Commentary:

What was the point of the Brit Week send off – it was pure fluffery.

The Carole King Medley - this was simply an atrocious choice like choosing to be stuck in an elevator in Coral Gables

No offense to the creative teams behind the Ford Music Videos - but tonight's was relatively pointless.

Wow to the Crystal Bowersox performance – it's sad to see she's gone down the country road right into irrelevancy.

The AT&T® questions of the Idol finalists?  If these were the best questions submitted, they shouldn't have bothered. They were just plain dull and self-indulgent. Clearly , they were more of a plug for the concept ofthan they were of any interest to anyone. Now, I'll be there were some interesting and relevant questions in the mix.

Result Revelations
Haley is safe!  1 point for America.
Why toy with Scotty, surely he's safe.
James is safe!  2 points for America.
Lauren is safe! 3 points USA.
Results are in random order.
Jacob is safe.
Clearly, it's Casey who will be gone.

Casey Abrams was announced as the one to be eliminated.

With all due respect to Casey's musicality, this was a long-overdue.  6 points for America.  They made the right call.  

It is just a shame that the true bottom 3 were not revealed.  It certainly wasn't Scotty.  My guess is it was Jacob and Lauren.

Casey's parting shot on the kitchen counter in the mansion standing and kicking stuff off was the sort of vintage odd boggery that became his signature and his downfall. Too bad, old chap, the immaturity finally took its toll.

Top 6 Performance Show – Lauren & Scotty


| Intro | Solos | Casey | Haley | Jacob | James | Lauren | Scotty |
| Duets: | Casey & Haley | Lauren & Scotty | James and Jacob|


"Up on the Roof" by Carole King
It was cute, not overly memorable.  Scotty's got the final three in the bag, but this won't have helped Lauren much.

Top 6 Performance Show – Lauren


| Intro | Solos | Casey | Haley | Jacob | James | Lauren | Scotty |
| Duets: | Casey & Haley | Lauren & Scotty | James and Jacob|



"Where You Lead" by Carole King
The outfit was atrocious and distracting.  This was a brilliant song choice that you made your own, I just wasn't overly impressed by your rendition which was borderline too harsh and screechy.  Your emotional attachment to the lyrics was non existent, which has been consistent.  That's not a good thing.  Randy said you showed some 'swagger' which is correct, but he's wrong about the song, the song was brilliant, the performance was not precisely because you has zero emotional involvement in the lyrics.

Thursday, April 21, 2011

7 Results Show – Group Performances

| Group Performances | Fan Poll Results |

Lauren, Haley, Jacob, and Stefano perform "Soul Sister" by Train

With all due respect to Train, after hearing the "Glee" version and now these guys, I wonder how everyone sings their song better than they do. This version wasn't quite as strong as the Warblers, but it most certainly was a lot of fun. Stefano was really in his element, and the girls were terrific. I cannot quite say the same thing for Jacob who simply isn't a "gangster thug".

Ford® Music Video with the American Idols® and the song "World"
By far the best vocal arrangement and performance of any of the videos. A perfect way to celebrate Earth Day.

Scotty, James, and Casey take on "Viva la Vida" by Cold Play
The opening line by Scotty proved exactly what I was talking about yesterday. James vocals and stage presence prove yet again he's got the most star quality of anyone up there with Scotty a close second. Casey, unfortunately, while vocally astute most of the times, those immature facial expressions and pouty teddy bear scruff just didn't fit with either the integrity of this powerfully moving song, nor the caliver of his singing partners. It's obvious who is the fish out of water. Unfortunatley, I hate to keep being so hard on him, but I've given critiques, and I don't see the improvements, not even little ones. Just watch the playback and look for the flubs. Casey was totally out of sync with teh choreography. I loved seeing James and Scotty perform this song. I woudl honestly pay to see them perform together as a duo. They were absolutely brilliant out of their comfort zones in this song proving they ranch of this dynamic duo. I did finally conclude that, sorry James, the scarves have got to go.

Wednesday, April 20, 2011

Top 7 Performance Show – Lauren


| Intro | Casey | Haley | Jacob | James | Lauren | Stefano | Scotty |



Chatty Southern Lauren
Trite and showing this was an idea that should have been saved a week or two since they all ran out of material after James and his magic scarves.

Lauren performs Sara Evans "Born to Fly"
Lauren, how did you think you did? Did you feel the difference between last week and this week? You're still not quite there, but that was so far beyond what you did last week, as to make me think you definitely deserve another week. Do you have that star quality? That something special that puts you on top of the world? You may just prove some of the naysayers wrong.


Afterthoughts
What if Ryan asked Simon, "Would you put Lauren through to the next round?"
Without a doubt, Lauren shows much more potential than some of the others who remain. I think she really just needs some more time building her confidence and accepting that she's got a really good voice so relax and have a little bit of fun with it.

Saturday, April 16, 2011

8 Perform – Who's Going Home Poll Results

Fan Poll Result for Week 8 – Who's Going Home?



Looks like the fans got it wrong as they predicted Haley. Better luck next time.

Thursday, April 14, 2011

8 Results Show – The Results

| Comments on Group Performances | Fan Poll Results |


Haley should in no way have been in the bottom three. This is a travesty. Of these four, I ouwld have picked Casey for certain. America got it wrong.

Stefano was a correct choice for the bottom as was Paul. I would have selected Jacob, however, rather than Haley. Haley waa so much stronger than Lauren.

Not getting voted off could be a turning point for Haley. She's got momentum on her side and experience in the bottom three to motivate her to reach the top three.

Should Paul have been selcted to go home, unfortunately, he has been a fish out of water for too long. He's a super nice guy, but nice doesn't necessarily sell records. He may have gotten too comfortable. He was one fo the most gracious losers ever. You will notice there wasn't a lot of crying. Perhaps Paul knew what to expect.

8 Results Show – Group Performances

Lauren & Scotty
Lauren lacked a bit of focus, but Scotty showed a more playful side. Overall It wasn't terrible.

Haley & Casey
While they played off each other well, their voices didn't get. I didn't get it. Haley was by far the better of the pair.

Paul, James, Jacob, and Stefano
Jacob was off key for half the first song. Everyone, however, shined together well for "Mrs. Robinson". James and Paul, especially stood out.

Wednesday, April 13, 2011

8 Perform – Haley


| Intro | Paul | Lauren | Stefano | Scotty | Casey | Jacob | James |


I find it fascinating that the judges finally gave a realistic critique this many weeks into the competition. It's unfortunate they picked you for it especially after Jennifer's plea to save the girls. Ironically, I wouldn't have been as hard on you as they were. You picked a very tough song, you are certainly not Debbie Harry, but compared to Lauren's poor Miley Cyrus, you were fantastic. You brought much more of a full package performance working the stage and commanding the audience than any other performance this evening so far. I liked you, and I think America's going to keep you around for a while. Take the criticism and grow. What do you grow from more, puppy love or tough love?


Afterthoughts
What if Ryan asked Simon, "Wow, is that the first close to a love critique you've given this season?"
I don't give love critiques. I just tell people honestly how it is. Haley's performance was one of her personal bests when it comes to overall stage presence and stage management. Were her vocals a little shaky in the beginning? Maybe, but there were three before her that were worse and were told nothing. I thought Haley was charming showed great showmanship. People talking about wanting to buy front row tickets, this was a performance worth selling. The question is, was this her one hit wonder or a window into what will be to come.

8 Perform – Lauren


| Intro | Paul | Stefano | Scotty | Casey | Haley | Jacob | James |


You know what I love about Lauren, that no one on this panel has an honest bone in their bodies. This was a poor song choice not because you couldn't have sung it well, nor because it's not a great song, but because you should have known you would have been too nervous which accounts for the shaky beginning and horribly mis-arranged ending. I did agree with Steven, you moved me to tears, just not the good kind. You're a beautiful girl who has potential, but you've got to be careful if you hope to have more weeks here let alone a real singing career.


Afterthoughts
What if Ryan asked Simon, "What should Lauren have done, Mr. White Tee?"
Ok, let's keep the comments on the contestants, Ryan, please. Ok, Lauren, seriously, you're young, but you're coming across as so young it's almost desperate. If you watched the TMZ crew go toe to toe with James when was it last week? There was one guy who told James he needed to tone it down when it comes to how he reacts to other celebrities. It's a maturity thing that when you start to break into the business you just don't go gaga all over your childhood idols. It's not dignified and it makes you look so juvenile. It's not your fault they aired all that stuff about you and your affection for this song and Miley Cyrus, but it just made you look so desperate, and that came through in your entire performance. What should you do, Lauren, sorry, but you need to grow up. You can sing, you really can, and there were glimpses of it in your performance tonight. You've got to gain confidence in yourself to ever make it here.