Click here to read what this author thinks Simon might have said during each show and after each contestant.

| 8 Perform | 8 Results | 7 Perform | 7 Results | 6 Perform |

Wednesday, April 13, 2011

Top 8 Performance Show: Intro

| Paul | Lauren | Stefano | Scotty | Casey | Haley | Jacob | James |

I'd like to start by saying I don't see why everyone was so surprised and there was such an uproar about Pia's elimination. First, this is a competition to find America's next Idol. That means someone's going home each week. Second, the judges used the save in week three on Casey. Don't cry over the loss of Pia when you used the save to keep a guy who looked like a cross between Michael J. Fox's Teen Wolf and an ordinary dust mop; and, sorry, he didn't perform much better. Pia's gone and somebody else will be going home this week. Get over it.

1 comment:

  1. You got this one totally right. I'm picking James to win it all. He was amazing, probably the best Idol ever! Yes, you read that here first!. I cannot get over how this kid with Asbergers is able to overcome his social stuff and just rock the stage with Zakk W. No freaking way! He's the only person I've downloaded tracks from iTunes from so far. By this time last year, I had bought like 25. This year, it's all about Scotty and James in my book. But Scotty doesn't have the pipes of James. He's got a style that will sell a million records to a million grandmas who like to listen to those dulcet tones while sipping mint juleps in their back porch rocking chairs, but James, James is a super star!